Menu
The Best Family Dog Debate
Samoyeds vs. Labradors, Retrievers, Oodles & More: The Ultimate Family Dog Showdown
There’s a reason Samoyeds have been beloved for centuries: they are the ultimate family pet, especially for households with children. But in a world where Golden Retrievers, Labradors, Maltese, Shih Tzus, Cavaliers, and Oodle breeds dominate the family dog conversation, it’s time for some controversial truth-telling. While these breeds have their merits, they also come with a slew of issues that make them less than ideal for families—especially compared to the incredible Samoyed.
From hypoallergenic properties to their friendly and tolerant nature, Samoyeds outperform these popular breeds in almost every category that matters to a family. So, let’s break down the reasons why Samoyeds reign supreme, while exposing the often-overlooked drawbacks of these so-called ‘family-friendly’ breeds.
.
Size Matters: The Advantage of a Medium Sized Dog
Samoyeds fall into the perfect size category for family life: large enough to be sturdy, yet not overwhelmingly massive. Unlike small breeds that can be easily injured, or giant breeds that may be difficult to manage, Samoyeds offer the best of both worlds. Their robustness means they can handle the energetic play of young children without reacting negatively, and they aren’t small enough to get underfoot and cause tripping hazards like a Cavalier or Maltese might.
People always tell me that when a Samoyed jumps up for a cuddle, they hold their own body weight so well that you barely feel them—it’s almost like a circus trick! Their agility makes them far less likely to knock over a small child compared to heavier breeds like Labradors or Golden Retrievers. Samoyeds have a unique honeycomb bone structure, making their bones lighter and less dense. Despite their fluffy appearance, samoyeds typically only weigh between 20-25kg, whereas Labradors and Golden Retrievers according to their breed standards often weigh between 30-35kg. This means Samoyeds are not only gentler but also easier for families to handle, particularly when it comes to managing a dog around young kids.
Tolerant and Gentle: Why Samoyeds Handle Kids Better
Families need a dog that is patient, gentle, and robust enough to handle the unpredictable antics of children. This is where Samoyeds excel. Their friendly, calm, and even-tempered nature makes them ideal companions for kids who might not always be gentle. Unlike smaller breeds like the Maltese, Shih Tzu, or Cavalier King Charles Spaniel, which are delicate and prone to injury, a Samoyed can withstand the occasional tail pull or accidental bump without reacting aggressively.
Small breeds often suffer from “small dog syndrome”—a defensive behaviour where they become snappy or anxious due to their size disadvantage. A Maltese or Shih Tzu may lash out or bite if a child steps on their paw, while a Samoyed is far more forgiving and tolerant. Cavaliers, though sweet, are fragile dogs that can easily be injured by rough play, making them less suitable for households with young children.
Additionally, while the general rule is that no dog should be left alone with a child—especially infants—Samoyeds have a unique history that sets them apart. Traditionally, the Samoyede people of Siberia entrusted these dogs to watch over their children while they were away hunting or gathering. Unlike other breeds, which may have been bred primarily for hunting or guarding, Samoyeds were developed as family companions, deeply trusted to care for and protect their human family members. Their instinctive gentleness and watchful nature make them one of the safest breeds for families, even among young children.
The Hypoallergenic Myth; Samoyeds Vs High-Allergen Breeds
One of the biggest concerns for families when choosing a dog is allergies. While no dog is truly 100% hypoallergenic, Samoyeds are far better suited for households with young children prone to allergies and sensitivities. Their unique double coat and minimal dander production make them one of the best breeds for allergy sufferers. In contrast, Oodle breeds (such as Labradoodles and Cavoodles) are often marketed as hypoallergenic, but the truth is, this varies drastically depending on the individual dog’s genetics. Many Oodles still shed and produce dander, making them a gamble for allergic households.
Golden Retrievers and Labradors, on the other hand, are among the worst offenders for allergy sufferers. These breeds shed constantly, releasing dander into the home every single day. If your child is sensitive to pet allergens, a Golden Retriever or Labrador could exacerbate their symptoms, leading to chronic discomfort.
No Dog Smell: The Unsung Benefit of Samoyeds
Let’s talk about something no one wants to admit: most dogs stink. Labradors and Golden Retrievers, in particular, are known for having a strong doggy odour, thanks to their oily coats that retain smells. If you’ve ever owned one of these breeds, you know the struggle of trying to keep your house from smelling like wet dog.
Samoyeds, however, are famously odourless. Their unique coat repels dirt and oils, meaning they don’t produce the same strong dog smell that plagues other breeds. This makes them far more pleasant to have indoors, especially for families who prefer a fresh-smelling home.
The Truth About Shedding: Why Samoyeds are Easier to Manage
The biggest myth about Samoyeds is that they shed excessively. The reality? They blow their coat once or twice a year, meaning they shed heavily in a short period but remain relatively clean for the rest of the time. Compare this to Retrievers and Labradors, which shed all year round. If you have a Golden Retriever, you’ll be vacuuming constantly. With a Samoyed, you’ll have a few weeks of intense shedding but significantly less hair around your home the rest of the year.
I’ve also owned a Shih Tzu, and I can confidently say that their coat is one of the hardest to maintain. It is highly prone to matting—no matter what I tried, within two days, my Shih Tzu would be matted again. Ask yourself, have you ever seen a Shih Tzu or a Maltese with a nice, well-kept coat at a dog park? The answer is no, because most owners can’t maintain their coats and end up shaving them down to the skin, which defeats the whole purpose of owning these breeds. And don’t get me started on Oodles… I am sure you could ask any groomer, and they’ll have plenty to say about them.
Meanwhile, Samoyeds are always the envy of the park. Their coat is surprisingly easy to maintain with the correct line combing technique, and they generally don’t mat with a simple six-weekly wash and blow dry routine. Check out our grooming page for mor hints and tips for keeping the fluffy white coats in emaculate condition! Most people agree that Samoyeds are the most aesthetic breed in the world, topped off with their signature Samoyed smile!
Energy and Intelligence: Why Samoyeds Are More Fun
A good family dog needs to be both energetic enough to keep up with kids and intelligent enough to train easily. Samoyeds fit the bill perfectly. They are playful, energetic, and love engaging in activities, making them fantastic playmates for children. Unlike Cavaliers and Shih Tzus, which tire quickly, or Oodles, which can be hyperactive and unpredictable, Samoyeds strike the perfect balance of fun and control.
Golden Retrievers and Labradors, while intelligent, often come with excessive energy levels that can be overwhelming for families. Their boundless enthusiasm can make them prone to destructive behaviours if not exercised properly, and their size means they can unintentionally knock over small children. Labradors, in particular, have a notorious reputation for chewing on furniture, shoes, and anything they can get their mouths on—something Samoyeds rarely do when properly trained.
The Samoyed’s Unique Bond: More Than Just a Pet
Samoyeds thrive on companionship and form deep emotional connections with their owners. They love simply being near you, often curling up at your feet just to enjoy your presence. Unlike Labradors, who constantly seek food and steal from kitchen counters, or Retrievers, who endlessly pester you to throw the ball, Samoyeds prioritise their relationship with their humans above their own desires. They truly connect with the human heart, making them one of the most emotionally intuitive breeds in the world. This is why Samoyeds are often recemmended as great service or therapy dogs.
Conclusion: The Undeniable Truth About Samoyeds
While other breeds have their appeal, none compare to the Samoyed when it comes to being the ultimate family pet. If you want a family dog that will provide years of love, laughter, and companionship, while also being easy to manage and train, the choice is clear: a Samoyed is the best investment you can make for your family.
Don’t be swayed by popular opinion—do your research, and you’ll see why Samoyeds are truly the superior choice for a family pet!
Newsletter
At Eskimoyed Samoyeds, we provide premium Samoyed puppies, raised with exceptional care and attention. Our dogs are well-socialized, embodying the perfect blend of beauty, intelligence, and friendliness.